¡De vuelta a la escuela!
“Hybrid” Diocesan Convention Planned for 2021
2021 Wardens’ Conference: Presentations and Recorded Sessions
A Child and a Miracle
A Sunday School Pandemic Journal
ACT: 50 Years and Looking Forward
Are We Teaching Our Children How to Live?
Arts Education Amidst a Pandemic
Back to School!
Breath of Freedom: Rural and Migrant Ministry’s Summer Overnight Leadership Camp
Campus Ministry Across the Diocese
Confirmands Get Creative
Covid on (and Off) Campus
Developing The Next Generation of Leaders
Diocesan Protocols for Covid 19 Now Mirror Those of the State of New York
Episcopal Charities Receives $1 Million Anonymous Donation
Episcopal Futures Learning Communities Launched at Pentecost
Grace Year: In Preparation for Leadership for the Common Good
Hacer espacio para dejar que los niños nos guíen
Introducing Rev. Kevin W. VanHook, II, the New Executive Director of Episcopal Charities
Jonathan Daniels Pilgrims Reflect
Kelly Latimore: Iconographer of a New Imago Dei
Make Space to Let the Children Lead Us
Mission of Our Youth: Poverty in New York
New Executive Director for Episcopal Charities
New Youth Grantmaking Board at Christ’s Church, Rye
Palm Sunday Hospitality with 10- and 11-Year-Olds
Pennoyer Appointed Head of Grace Church School
PPP Loans: Reminder to Congregations to Apply for Loan Forgiveness if You Qualify
Prayers from Our Hearts
Report from the St. Margaret’s and St. Luke’s Branches of the Girls’ Friendly Society
Seeing Past the Horizon
The Journey
Un niño y un milagro
Video Hit: St. James’ children’s ministries series Did You Know?
Voices Heard: A Diocese Explores Pathways Toward Reparations
We Need All Ages
When I Was a Child: The Beginnings of Faith
Home » Enlivening and Enriching Doubt
Print this article

Enlivening and Enriching Doubt

Published in the issue.

“Whoever does not receive the kingdom of God like a child shall not enter it.” These well-known words of Jesus, as reported in Luke’s Gospel (17:18), are often interpreted to mean that our faith should be simple and accepting, even unquestioning—just as we imagine innocent little children believe. Yet, as any parent or teacher knows, children actually ask a lot of questions. When they do, it is often not that they doubt what they’re told, but because they want to understand more fully.

In the context of religious faith, doubt often gets a bad rap. One need only consider that personification of skepticism, “Doubting Thomas,” the apostle who would not believe that Christ had risen from the dead until he personally saw Jesus’s wounds and touched them with his own fingers.

The word “doubt” has long been part of our language. Its Latin root, dubitare, means “to doubt, question, hesitate, waver in opinion.” In Old French, doute meant “uncertainty with regard to the truth of something.” Could it be that we have too long focused on doubt’s negative aspects? If instead we considered “doubt” in its questioning guise—as in opening a path to learning—mightn’t it potentially enliven and enrich our journey in faith?

It seems to me that a more questioning posture in our world in general would benefit us in various ways. Take our news sources. We hear so much about “misinformation,” “fake news,” “Big Tech censorship,” and “media bias.” It seems naïve, if not dangerous, not to probe beyond what we’re fed so that we get a more complete picture. Surely our faith is likewise strong enough to bear sincere and honest scrutiny in our quest for knowledge.

These days it seems that certainty in anything at all is scarce, and chances are we questioners have plenty of company. As Father Flynn, the priest whose alleged misdeeds are the play’s fulcrum, declares in John Patrick Shanley’s Doubt: A Parable, “Doubt can be a bond as powerful and sustaining as certainty. When you are lost, you are not alone.”

But daring to question long or rigidly held beliefs, or to express an unpopular opinion, often requires courage. In today’s world, we risk the wrath of the “cancel culture.” In 1615, the astronomer and polymath Galileo Galilei (who was a devout Catholic) paid a high price when he endorsed the Copernican theory that the earth revolved daily around the sun. Galileo’s pronouncements, based on his own scientific work, contradicted the Church’s own position. The Roman Inquisition found Galileo guilty of heresy and forced him to recant; he spent the rest of his life under house arrest. History, of course, has since proved Galileo correct.

Obviously, Galileo did not find religious faith and intellectual honesty mutually exclusive, a point we all might remember as we deal with our own doubt. As he wrote in a 1615 letter in his own defense, “I do not feel obliged to believe that the same God who has endowed us with sense, reason, and intellect intended us to forgo their use.”